Daniel L Carpenter Law LLC Employment-Based Immigration

FAQ

Frequently asked questions

The questions I get asked most, answered briefly. These are general answers. If your situation has a wrinkle, ask me directly.

Working with the firm

Do you represent clients outside Massachusetts?

Yes. Practice before U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services and the Department of Labor is federal, so a lawyer admitted in any state may represent clients in those matters wherever the client is located. I’m admitted in Massachusetts and represent clients throughout the United States and abroad.

If you're applying at a U.S. embassy, consulate, or port of entry, I prepare the application and supporting documents and get you ready for the interview or inspection. Attorneys generally can’t attend consular interviews or border inspections, but you’ll walk in knowing what to expect.

Who will I actually be working with?

Me. Consultations are scheduled directly with me, with no intake coordinator in between, and clients work with me from the first consultation through adjudication.

I work with a small number of clients at a time, which means the person who knows your matter is the person who answers your email.

I'm holding a notice with a deadline. What should I do?

Say so in the first line of your message. Requests for Evidence, audit notifications, and notices of intent to deny all carry response periods that are short and are not routinely extended, and I'll move a matter with a deadline to the front.

What kinds of matters do you handle?

The practice focuses on employment-based immigration, along with naturalization and some family-based cases. I don’t handle asylum or removal defense.

Hiring on a temporary work visa

Our candidate wasn't selected in the H-1B lottery. What now?

The lottery is the default path, not the only one. Three questions sort out most of the alternatives: what passport your candidate holds, whether your company has a related entity abroad they have worked for, and how strong their record is.

Depending on the answers, TN, E-3, H-1B1, E-1/E-2, L-1, O-1A, or a cap-exempt H-1B may be available now, without waiting for the next registration period.

Read more: H-1B Cap Alternatives →

Which work visas aren't subject to a lottery?

For most professional roles, H-1B is the only temporary work category gated by a lottery. Cap-exempt H-1B, L-1, and O-1 are not, and the treaty categories either have no cap or have caps that are rarely reached.

Read more: Temporary Work Visas →

What is dual intent, and why does it matter?

Some temporary categories accommodate an intention to remain in the United States permanently and some do not. H-1B, L-1, and O-1 do; TN, E-3, and H-1B1 do not.

It matters because the issue often shows up years later. Starting green card sponsorship for someone in a category without dual intent may cause trouble at the next extension or entry, so if permanent residence is the eventual plan, it should shape the temporary category you choose now.

Read more: Temporary Work Visas →

Sponsoring a green card

Does every employer-sponsored green card require PERM?

No. PERM followed by an EB-2 or EB-3 petition is the default route, and the one most employers assume is the only option. EB-1B (for outstanding researchers and professors) and EB-1C (for multinational managers and executives) are employer petitions with no labor market test, no recruitment, and no prevailing wage timeline.

EB-1A and the national interest waiver (NIW) also skip PERM. An employer can file either one, or the employee can petition for themselves.

Read more: Green Card Sponsorship →

When should we start the green card process?

Earlier than feels necessary. For PERM, involve counsel before the prevailing wage request is filed, since the job description and requirements set there carry through the whole process. Before starting anything, check how much time the employee has left in their current status and whether that status accommodates dual intent. For H-1B workers, that means checking the six-year limit early.

Read more: PERM Labor Certification →

Why does an employee's country of birth matter?

Every route has two clocks: how long it takes to get the petition approved, and how long the employee then waits for an immigrant visa number. The second depends on classification and country of birth, and for some employees it dominates everything else.

That's why the choice of category is more than a paperwork question, and why backlogs are worth checking against the current Visa Bulletin rather than against what was true two years ago.

Read more: Green Card Sponsorship →

Can an employee get a green card without us sponsoring them?

Possibly. In EB-1A and the EB-2 national interest waiver (NIW), the employee can be the petitioner. When they self-petition, there’s no employer petition, no job offer, and no labor certification, and none of the recruitment, prevailing wage, or ability-to-pay obligations that come with sponsorship.

In a self-petition, your role is small, usually a letter describing the significance of the employee’s work and access to records that document its impact. The honest trade is that the case belongs to the employee and travels with them if they leave.

Read more: EB-1A & NIW: Retaining Talent Without PERM →

Petitioning for yourself

Can I get a green card without an employer sponsoring me?

In two categories, yes. EB-1A and the EB-2 national interest waiver (NIW) can be filed by you, with no petitioning employer, no job offer, and no labor certification. Both set a high bar, and they ask different questions.

Read more: EB-1A Extraordinary Ability →

What's the difference between EB-1A and the national interest waiver (NIW)?

EB-1A asks about acclaim: are you at the top of your field, and does the field recognize it? The national interest waiver (NIW) asks about the work: does the endeavor have substantial merit and national importance, and are you well positioned to advance it?

Those questions can have different answers for the same person, and neither category is the junior version of the other.

Read more: EB-2 National Interest Waiver →

Can I file an O-1 petition for myself?

No. An O-1 petition must be filed by a U.S. employer or by a qualifying agent. That said, a U.S. company you own can be the employer, and agent arrangements can make the category workable for founders, consultants, and researchers who split their time across institutions.

O-1A is also not a green card. It authorizes work for a defined period, though the record you build for it overlaps substantially with what EB-1A later requires.

Read more: O-1A Extraordinary Ability →

How do I know whether my record is strong enough?

Ask, and expect a straight answer in the first conversation. I’ll tell you whether you have an EB-1A case, a national interest waiver (NIW) case, both, or a promising record that needs deliberate work before either is worth filing.

Filing before a petition is ready has real costs. A denial takes time and money, and it can make the next attempt harder.

Read more: EB-1A Extraordinary Ability →

Citizenship

When can I apply to become a U.S. citizen?

Generally after five years as a permanent resident, or three if you have been married to and living with the same U.S. citizen for that period. Your residence must have been continuous, and you must have been physically present in the United States for at least half of it.

Those are two different tests. A single long trip abroad can break continuous residence even when the day count is comfortable.

Current and former members of the U.S. military, and in some cases their spouses, may qualify sooner or under different rules.

Read more: Naturalization / U.S. Citizenship →

Is naturalization just paperwork?

Not quite. The application invites a full review of how you became a permanent resident, and an approval years ago does not settle the question. For employment-based residents, a role that changed or an employer you left quickly is better addressed in a prepared application than in an interview.

Read more: Naturalization / U.S. Citizenship →

Let's talk about your matter.

Consultations are scheduled directly with me. If you're facing a filing deadline say so first and I'll prioritize it.

Schedule a consultation Send a message

[email protected] · (508) 591-0775 · Kingston, Massachusetts